Practice Areas

Premises Liability, Negligent Security & Dram Shop

Premises Liability, Negligent Security & Dram Shop

When Safety Corners Are Cut, We Step In. Accountability for Catastrophic Harm.

When a business, property owner, or alcohol‑serving establishment fails to meet basic duties of safety, people get hurt. These duties are simple: maintain the property in a reasonably safe condition, provide security proportional to known risks, and refuse service to intoxicated patrons and minors. When those safeguards are ignored, preventable events including assaults in dimly lit parking garages, falls on unmarked hazards, balcony and stair failures, alcohol‑related crashes, etc., upend lives in an instant.

McEldrew Purtell represents victims and families in complex premises liability, negligent security, and dram shop cases nationwide. We move quickly to preserve surveillance and incident data, inspect the scene, and retain the right experts so the truth is documented before it disappears. Our team routinely handles matters with multiple corporate defendants, layered insurance coverage, and highly technical evidence.

Premises Liability

Premises Liability, Negligent Security & Dram Shop Lawyers

With decades of experience in catastrophic injury and wrongful death litigation, our lawyers are equipped to navigate cases involving multiple defendants, layered insurance coverage, and highly technical evidence. We assemble the right team for each matter—investigators, code‑compliance and security experts, toxicologists, accident reconstructionists, and life‑care planners—so the facts speak clearly and powerfully.

Our Results

McEldrew Purtell has a proven track record of maximizing recovery for our clients.

$8,500,000
Premises Liability
$6,000,000
Premises Liability
$4,000,000
Premises Liability
$1,350,000
Premises Liability

Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances.

This guide is a for victims and referring attorneys that explains premises liability, negligent security, and dram shop claims – covering common case types, key legal elements, current stats and verdict examples, immediate post-incident best practices, and how to choose the right attorney.

Ways We Can Help

Premises liability, negligent security, and dram shop cases demand immediate action and specialized expertise. Whether the harm occurred in a store, apartment complex, parking garage, hotel, or alcohol‑serving venue, our team knows how to secure and analyze the evidence that proves negligence.

Unsafe Conditions


Too many falls happen because retailers cut corners on inspections and hazard removal. We uncover neglect by locking down surveillance before it’s overwritten and pulling sweep logs, incident reports, and employee statements to prove the danger was left on the floor.

Structural & Code Violations


Serious injuries follow when owners sidestep building codes—loose handrails, uneven steps, missing guards, unstable shelving. We prove violations with code‑qualified experts, site documentation, and demonstratives that tie the defect directly to the injury.

Deferred Maintenance


Guests and residents pay the price for deferred maintenance—broken locks, dark corridors, malfunctioning doors, elevators, and escalators. We expose patterns through work orders, vendor service records, access‑control/smart‑key logs, and lighting measurements.

Violent Crime on Property


Many assaults happen because landlords ignore known crime patterns. We prove foreseeability with police call‑for‑service data, prior‑incident histories, and expert analysis of staffing and response times.

Security Failures


Corners get cut on lighting, camera coverage/retention, trained personnel, and access control. We test and audit lighting levels and sightlines, camera placement and retention policies, and compare protocols to industry standards (including CPTED) to show security on paper – not in practice.

Missed Precautions


When danger was obvious, management had options – locks, fencing, controlled entry, roving patrols, or warnings. We connect the dots between what they knew and what they refused to implement.

Overserving Intoxicated Patrons


Too many establishments prioritize sales over safety, continuing to pour for visibly intoxicated guests. We reconstruct the night with POS data, tabs/receipts, time‑stamped video, witness interviews, and toxicology/retrograde BAC to link overservice to the crash or assault.

Service to Minors


Lax ID checks and illegal sales fuel predictable tragedies. We document unlawful service through training records, licensing/compliance histories, surveillance, and staff testimony.

Corporate Accountability


Chains and franchise owners try to shift blame to individual servers. We pursue accountability up the corporate ladder and across all applicable insurance to secure full compensation.

On behalf of my entire family, thank you for all your hard work and determination in representing us in our case. We are grateful for all your compassion, support, & encouragement throughout the entire process. You are an excellent attorney with a bright future ahead of you. Thank you for helping us to stand up for my dad. Wishing you all the best going forward in both your professional and personal life.

Sylvan Garfunkel

Medical Malpractice

Thank you so much for all you did for me. This outcome would never have happened without you!!

Catastrophic Injury Client

Thank you for a job well done and an outcome well beyond expectations. I’m truly amazed at the amount of investigation, leg work and effort you and your law firm put into winning my case in a 7-day jury trial. I’m now able to move on with my life and support myself and family. Thank you again.

Railroad Worker

McEldrew Purtell stepped in and immediately went to work making sure I was able to get everything I deserved. They kept me informed step by step as the process went on. They assured me that even when things were looking bleak, they were not going to stop fighting, and that is exactly what they have done. Fought and won!

Michael

Catastrophic Injury

After being injured on the job, I hired McEldrew Purtell despite my positive history with another lawyer because I found them to be highly competent and people who truly care about their clients. Throughout the case process, they showed over and over to me and my fellow linemen buddies how generous they are with their time and resources.

Former SEPTA Lineman

Injured on the Job

Hear From Our Clients

At McEldrew Purtell, results matter and so does the way we achieve them. While our case outcomes reflect our tenacity in court and at the negotiation table, it’s the voices of our clients that truly capture who we are and why we do this work.

We represent people at the worst moments of their lives: after catastrophic injuries, workplace tragedies, and preventable losses. Through every case, we aim to deliver not just compensation but clarity, confidence, and care.

If you’re considering working with a Philadelphia trial lawyer, we invite you to read what our clients have said about their experiences with McEldrew Purtell. Their words are the most powerful testament to our values, our dedication, and our results.

Learn More

6 Advantages of Dram Shop Lawyers in Alcohol-Related Accidents

About 37 people every day lose their lives in drunk driving accidents, according to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. As sobering as this statistic is, accidents involving drunk drivers are just one possible tragic outcome of excessive drinking. Property damage,…

The Ins and Outs of Dram Shop Law

Dram shops laws apply to bars, restaurants, and anywhere else where alcohol is served. These laws hold responsible sellers of alcohol who overserve customers when those customers cause an injury due to their intoxication. These often arise from personal injury…

Injured in a Walmart? Why Walmart Lawsuits Are More Common Than You Might Think

You can find just about any product you need in a Walmart, from tires and oil changes to clothing, groceries, and financial services. But you can also be injured there in a variety of ways, from slipping and falling on…

What Is Dram Shop Law?

An Overview of Dram Shop Law Dram shop laws hold an owner liable for selling alcohol to a customer who then injured someone else. Examples of its application include injuries caused by drunk driving accidents or fights. Not every state…

Dog Bite Laws in Pennslyvania

Dog bite injuries are more common than you may realize. The number of dog bite cases is rising nationwide, with Pennsylvania experiencing one of the biggest increases. Pennsylvania has dog bite laws to compensate victims of dog bites in many circumstances.…

When a Slip-And-Fall Leads To Wrongful Death

Slip-and-fall accidents are some of the most common accidents to occur. This is because there are many things that can cause it to happen, including uneven pavement, icy roads, unseen puddles, and upturned rugs. For some, a slip-and-fall accident may…

FAQs

Get answers to commonly asked questions regarding premises liability, negligent security & dram shop cases and learn how we can help.

In personal injury law, premises liability cases deal with incidents caused by an unsafe or defective condition on someone’s property.

Premises liability cases depend on two factors — the negligence of the owner and/or renter of the space where the injury occurred, and a lack of fault in the plaintiff. Proprietors, landlords and homeowners have a duty to keep their property free from serious hazards. If they fail to do so and someone gets hurt while exercising reasonable diligence, the site operator may be held responsible.

Negligent security applies to both commercial and residential properties. While it falls under liability law, it generally holds a property owner liable for negligence in cases of injury or damages that occur due to lack of sufficient security or safety measures. These security oversights can result in injury.

Locations most often liable include but are not limited to:

  • Theaters
  • Airports
  • Amusement Parks
  • Apartment buildings
  • Concert venues
  • Grocery stores
  • Hospitals/Nursing Homes
  • Office buildings
  • Parking garages
  • Schools/Universities 
  • Shopping malls/centers
  • Sporting stadiums

A civil claim against a business that sells/serves alcohol (e.g., bar, restaurant, liquor store) for harm caused by an intoxicated or underage patron whom they unlawfully served. Most jurisdictions focus on injuries to third parties; some allow claims by the intoxicated person, too.

These cases often involve corporate defendants, multiple insurers, complex evidentiary issues (like surveillance retention and POS data), and specialized standards for security and alcohol service. Experience and early evidence preservation are critical.

Depending on the facts: the property owner, property manager, commercial tenant, third‑party security company, maintenance contractors, franchisor/franchisee, and alcohol‑serving establishments that overserved an intoxicated patron or served a minor.

Insurers and corporations often deny or shift blame. We perform a thorough investigation, retain the right experts, and pursue every responsible party to maximize accountability and recovery.

No. A criminal DUI is separate. Civil liability usually requires proof the vendor served a minor or someone visibly intoxicated at the time of service, plus causation.

Varies by state. Pennsylvania: No civil liability for serving adults (Klein v. Raysinger), but hosts can be liable for furnishing alcohol to minors (Congini v. Portersville Valve Co.). For broader state patterns on social-host laws, see NCSL’s 50-state resource.

A property owner is held to two expectations within their “duty of care” — first, they must undertake reasonable measures to ensure their property is safe, and second, they should foresee any harm that may occur from the conditions on their property.

Premises liability cases are often caused by:

  • A hidden defect on a walking surface, like a broken stair
  • Snow, ice or water left on walkways
  • Defective electrical wiring
  • Poor construction using cheap materials
  • Building code violations
  • Slippery floors
  • Lack of maintenance
  • Lack of signage
  • Messy and poorly-lit areas
  • Uneven, broken sidewalks
  • Design flaws on the property

The value of a premises liability claim depends on the extent of the injuries suffered, provided that the plaintiff has done everything in their power to mitigate their injuries. The losses aimed for in a settlement will cover both accident-related expenses and non-economic losses, including:

  • Current and future medical bills
  • Current and future lost wages from missed work
  • Physical therapy
  • Pain and suffering
  • Wrongful death (in the event of losing a loved one)

Property owners are responsible for taking necessary actions to ensure that visitors and tenants have minimal risk while on the premises. If inadequate action is taken and injuries occur as a result, the property owners can be at fault.

Understanding if you are a victim of negligent security where property owners may be held liable can be beneficial to you and your law team. Here are some of the most common:

Faulty Access Control: If the property has broken or malfunctioning locks, gates, fencing or security access systems. Property owners can be held liable if unauthorized individuals are able to gain access, resulting in harm to authorized patrons. These cases most often involved apartment complexes, gated communities, and office buildings.

Missing or Inadequate Security Systems: Property owners are responsible for proper and regular maintenance of security systems. If they are not adequately monitored, maintained, or are missing from an area deemed high-risk and an incident occurred, property owners can be held liable if the system fails to provide evidence.

Inadequate Lighting: Broken, missing or insufficient lighting can create an environment where assaults and robberies are more likely to occur. Property owners should ensure that all walkways and key access points are well-lit and regularly maintained.

Lack or Inadequate Security Personnel: Property owners are responsible for ensuring that they have adequately staffed and trained security personnel. Patrons expect that security staff on properties are trained to manage a variety of potential situations, not just act as a deterrent. Additionally, there should be adequate security staffing to safely manage the entire property.

Negligent Hiring: In some cases, property owners may be negligent by not performing adequate background checks that lead to harmful behaviors by staff that they have hired.