Accountability when jails and prisons ignore serious medical needs.
People donât surrender their right to basic medical care when theyâre arrested or incarcerated. Yet preventable injuries, overdoses, suicides, assaults, and deaths happen behind bars every day because symptoms are ignored, care is delayed, or safety protocols are not followed. Survivors face lifelong harm. Families are left without answers.
At McEldrew Purtell, we move quickly to secure evidence, challenge official narratives, and hold agencies, private medical contractors, and individual actors accountable. Our goal is twofold: justice for your family and pressure for reforms that prevent the next tragedy.


How Much Is Your Case Worth?

What counts as denial of medical care?
You may have a civil rights claim when a person in custody has a serious medical need and officials are deliberately indifferent – ignoring obvious symptoms, delaying treatment, or failing to follow required monitoring and safety policies. Common scenarios include:
- Medical emergencies ignored or delayed (stroke, heart attack, seizures, anaphylaxis)
- Detox & withdrawal failures (opioids, alcohol, benzodiazepines), missed CIWA/COWS monitoring, no MAT offered
- Suicide risk & mental-health neglect (inadequate screening, missed watch rounds, unsafe housing)
- Overdose incidents (missed searches, no naloxone, slow response)
- Diabetic crises & chronic condition lapses (withheld insulin/meds, diet lapses)
- Infections & sepsis (ignored fever/wounds)
- Heat, dehydration & environmental hazards (extreme temperatures, lack of water, unsanitary units)
- Use of force or restraints followed by delayed or denied medical evaluation
- Assaults by officers or other incarcerated people where known risks were ignored or housing was unsafe
How these failures happen and how we prove them.
In-custody medical neglect is usually a chain of preventable failures, not a single mistake. We build the record that shows where systems broke down:
- Timeline reconstruction: minute-by-minute mapping of symptoms, help requests, rounds, and response times
- Evidence preservation: medical charts, MARs, sick-call slips, watch/round logs, incident reports, radio traffic, bodycam & fixed cameras
- Policy & contractor review: written policies, training materials, staffing rosters, vendor contracts, audits
- Witness development: cellmates, line officers, nurses, transport/EMS, outside hospital staff
- Independent experts: correctional medicine, emergency medicine, psychiatry, toxicology, pathology, use-of-force, jail operations

Your Legal Avenues
We tailor strategy to the facts, jurisdiction, and the strongest path to accountability.
Civil Rights (42 U.S.C. § 1983)
Deliberate indifference to serious medical needs; failure-to-protect; due-process violations for pretrial detainees.
Wrongful Death & Survival Actions
Recovery for the familyâs losses and the decedentâs conscious pain and suffering.
Monell Liability
When unconstitutional policies, customs, or training/supervision failures cause violations, the municipality (or policy-making entity) can be liable.
Related State-Law Claims
Negligence, assault/battery, negligent hiring/retention/supervision, depending on the facts.
Learn More
McEldrew Purtell Files PCRA Petition Seeking Release of Michael Gaynor in 1988 Marcus Yates Case
McEldrew Purtell has filed a petition under Pennsylvaniaâs Post-Conviction Relief Act (PCRA) seeking the release of Michael Gaynor, who has been incarcerated since his 1988 conviction in the tragic shooting death of 5-year-old Marcus Yates.
Family of Amanda Cahill Files Federal Lawsuit After Jail Overdose
McEldrew Purtell has filed a federal lawsuit on behalf of the family of Amanda Cahill, a 31-year-old mother who died in September 2024 of a suspected fentanyl overdose while incarcerated at the Philadelphia Industrial Correctional Center (PICC).
Baton Rouge Police Department Strip-Search Class Action: What Victims Should Know (2025 Update)
The Baton Rouge Police Department Systematically violated the rights of citizens by taking them into custody, strip searching, and physically abusing them without justification or legitimate purpose. The officers and supervisors who committed these violations were in a specialized unit…
McEldrew Purtell is currently investigating the New Orleans Terror Attack
In the early hours of New Yearâs Eve, tragedy struck when a devastating attack led to unimaginable loss and injury. Many lives were changed forever, and the community is still reeling from the effects. At McEldrew Purtell, we stand with…
$1.6 Million Settlement: Wrongful Death in Prison
Our Civil Rights Team led by Mark V. Maguire reached a $1.6 million settlement for the estate of Marvin David Scott III, who was wrongfully killed by police officers while in custody. Mr. Scott was under arrest for a misdemeanor of…
$1.25 Million Settlement: Civil Rights Matter
Attorney Mark Maguire of our civil rights team secured $1.25 million for the estate of Damien Daniels, an Army veteran, wrongfully killed by police during a welfare check. On August 25, 2020, Damien Daniels was shot twice in the chest…
